|
|
Musings Report #31 7-31-15 Could China's Housing Bubble Bring Down the Global Economy?
You are receiving this email because you are one of the 500+ subscribers/major contributors to www.oftwominds.com.
For those who are new to the Musings reports: they are basically a glimpse into my notebook,the unfiltered swamp where I organize future themes, sort through the dozens of stories and links submitted by readers, refine my own research and start connecting dots which appear later in the blog or in my books. As always, I hope the Musings spark new appraisals and insights. Thank you for supporting the site and for inviting me into your circle of correspondents.
Could China's Housing Bubble Bring Down the Global Economy?
I've been writing a lot about China recently because it's becoming increasingly clear that China's economy is slowing and the authorities' "fixes" are not turning it around. That means the engine that pulled the global economy out of the 2009 recession has stalled.
Many people see China's slowdown as the source of the next global recession, but few seem to realize the extreme vulnerability of China's vast housing market and the many knock-on consequences of that market grinding to a halt.
I've just completed a comprehensive review of China's housing market, and now realize it's much worse than the consensus understands.
The consensus view is: Sure, China's housing prices are falling modestly outside of Beijing and Shanghai, but since Chinese households buy homes with cash or large down payments, this decline won't trigger a banking crisis like America's housing bubble did in 2008.
The problem isn't a banking crisis; it's a loss of household wealth, the reversal of the wealth effect and the decimation of local government budgets and the construction sector.
China is uniquely dependent on housing and real estate development. This makes it uniquely vulnerable to any slowdown in construction and sales of new housing.
About 15% of China's GDP is housing-related. This is extraordinarily high. In the 2003-08 housing bubble, housing's share of U.S. GDP barely cracked 5%.
Of even greater concern, local governments in China depend on land development sales for roughly 2/3 of their revenues. (These are not fee simple sales of land, but the sale of leasehold rights, as all land in China is owned by the state.)
There is no substitute source of revenue waiting in the wings should land sales and housing development grind to a halt. Local governments will lose 2/3 of their operating revenues, and there is no other source they can tap to replace this lost revenue.
Since China authorized private ownership of housing in the late 1990s, homeowners in China have only experienced rising prices and thus rising household wealth--at least until very recently, when prices dipped as the government tightened lending standards and imposed some restrictions on the purchase of flats as investments.
Though it's difficult to quantify the "wealth effect" the rapid rise in housing valuations supported, it's widely acknowledged that upper-middle class household spending has increased as a direct result of housing's wealth effect.
Though few dare acknowledge it, prices in desirable first-tier cities urban cores are completely unaffordable to average households. Average flats in Beijing now cost 22X annual household income -- roughly six times the income-price ratio that is sustainable (3 or 4 X income = affordable cost of a house).
Far too many observers use housing prices and sales in Beijing and Shanghai--a mere 3.5% of China's population and housing stock--as the basis of entire nation's housing market. This is akin to judging America's housing market on prices and sales in Manhattan.
So while sales are soaring in Beijing, they're falling 26% in the 2nd, 3rd and 4th tier cities.
Though it is widely known that China's household wealth is concentrated in housing, the extent and consequences of this concentration are rarely discussed.
Much has been made of the $3+ trillion losses households have suffered as China's stock market bubble collapsed. But given the relatively insignificant role financial assets play in household wealth, these losses are modest compared to the far larger loss of household wealth that will occur as housing deflates from bubble heights.
Many people claim the estimated 65 million empty flats held as investments by the middle and upper classes in China will be sold to new buyers in due time. But these complacent analysts overlook the grim reality that the vast majority of urban workers make around $6,000 to $10,000 annually, and a $200,000 flat is permanently out of reach.
They also overlook the extreme concentration of wealth that goes into every purchase of a small flat by households that really can't afford the cost: the entire extended family's wealth is often poured into the flat, along with money borrowed from friends and relatives or even loan sharks.
The other problem few Western analysts consider is the impaired nature of much of China's housing stock. Millions of units constructed in the early 2000s were hastily built and are now degraded. Newer buildings are not maintained, either, and there is a strong cultural preference for new homes, not existing units. (The government doesn't even keep track of resales/sales of existing homes; whatever minimal data is available comes from private brokerages).
This raises a core question--who's going to buy the tens of millions of empty flats held as investments? What is the market value of flats nobody wants to buy or cannot afford to buy?
China has a demographic problem as well. The generation now entering the work force is much smaller than the generation that bought two or three flats for investment. There simply aren't enough wage earners entering the primary home-buying years to soak up this vast and growing inventory of empty homes.
China's stated intent is to move from a fixed-investment/export dependent economy to a consumer economy. But if we consider what happens when housing slows or even grinds to a halt, we realize the impact on incomes, wealth and consumption will be extraordinarily negative, not just for China but for every nation that sells China vehicles and other consumer goods.
Summary of the Blog This Past Week
The Cost of Stagnation: We're Living in Limbo 7/31/15
7 "Saves" in 7 Months: A Market Going Nowhere Fast 7/30/15
Currency Devaluation: The Crushing Vice of Price 7/29/15
Does "Creative Destruction" Include the State? 7/28/15
When Authorities "Own" the Market, The System Breaks Down: Here's Why 7/27/15
Best Thing That Happened To Me This Week
Home-made cherry pie!
Market Musings: Oil (WTIC)
In June, I posted a chart that suggested oil might find support in the low $40s.
We're approaching that area (currently $46-$48), but it's too soon to say whether that level will hold. If a global recession takes hold, demand will fall sharply and price will follow.
Price might hold this time around, but fail later in 2015 should the engines of the global economy (i.e. China, Germany, U.S.) weaken.
There's a lot of speculation about the future price of oil; let's see if support holds as Iran's oil exports increase and demand weakens.
From Left Field
The unlikely friendship of a dog and an owl (via John S.-P.)
China’s urban consumers depend on property ‘wealth effect’ -- no surprise....
Russell Napier: What Happens When Markets Realize China Is A Forced Seller Of Treasuries (via Lew G.)
What’s wrong with GDP? Dirk Philipsen argues we need to make economic questions political again
Inequality - the 99% in ancient times -- the scholarly comments are interesting...
If Capitalism is Sociopathic, How Should We Make a Living? -- what kind of capitalism are we discussing? Crony state/cartel "capitalism"? Yes, that version is sociopathological...
Musk, Wozniak and Hawking urge ban on warfare AI and autonomous weapons -- remember the recent Musings on the subject?
Shrinking in Real Time: Cheap orbiting cameras and big-data software reveal hidden secrets of life down below -- this is a game-changer... economic data can be collected from space, no need to rely on phony state stats....
Leaving Los Angeles: The dream of living here comes at a price. A writer contemplates parting ways with the city he can no longer afford -- yeah, him and a couple million others...
The Frenzy About High-Tech Talent -- too many STEM graduates....this is important...
The Housing Value of Every County in the U.S.
The ‘Busy’ Trap: Busyness serves as a kind of existential reassurance, a hedge against emptiness; obviously your life cannot possibly be silly or trivial or meaningless if you are so busy, completely booked, in demand every hour of the day.
"The hardest thing to do is how to unlearn the secrets of your past success." Jiro Tokuyama (via Betty L.)
Thanks for reading--
charles |
|
|
|
|
|
