weblog/wEssays archives | home | |
Iraq and Vietnam: A Nam Vet's View (December 28, 2006) When viewing the war in Iraq through the lens of the Vietnam War, it's critical to listen to the voices of those who actually served in Vietnam--such as correspondent Steve S., who responded to my December 19 post "Defeat and Over-Confidence." The post noted that two consecutive Republican over-55 males dismissed the 3,000 U.S. combat deaths in Iraq as insignicant, since 3,000 Americans had been murdered on the streets of Los Angeles in the same timeframe. (A "fact" unchecked by me.) Steve, a veteran of the Vietnam War, made a point which I haven't seen in print anywhere else: A big lesson I learned was while serving for 14 months in Vietnam: I took a R&R (Rest and Recreation) in Thailand in the middle of my tour. (I actually volunteered to go to 'Nam so that I could express my disagreement without being called a coward by the love-it-or-leave-it crowd.) Thailand had a topography and people very similar to much of Vietnam, however the people were smiling. In 'Nam, smiles were rare, the country smelled, homes were rubble. The difference was largely war. No matter how bad the government was, it could not make the drastic difference I saw between the two countries. Communism was better than war anyday.Steve added this comment about the relative significance of 3,000 deaths: It is amazing that 3,000 dead on Sept 11 was significant enough to initiate this embarrassing disaster. Additionally, while 40,000 die on our highways, half through alcohol abuse every year and 30,000 die from guns in our country every year, we do not want to do anything about that--serious DWI and speeding laws could be written or enforced and better gun control could be supported by Republicans. Hypocrisy. Additionally, since the annual 'terrorist' caused deaths have been in the low hundreds worldwide other than the Mideast since that day, the terrorist threat is politically manufactured by those who love walls, love hate, and love ignorance for selfish reasons.Excellent points, Steve--points which rarely make the major media or comparisons of Vietnam to Iraq. War is an extended instability with unpredictable consequences. Eventually, a new equilibrium or stability is reached; but will it be the form we hoped for, or one entirely different from the rosy expectations of 2003? For more on this subject and a wide array of other topics, please visit my weblog. copyright © 2006 Charles Hugh Smith. All rights reserved in all media. I would be honored if you linked this wEssay to your site, or printed a copy for your own use. |
||
weblog/wEssays | home |