weblog/wEssays     home
 

The World Is Not a U.S. Suburb   (January 25, 2006)


We are all prisoners of our own experience. This leads us into thinking that other people and other cultures are much like our own; they are not. It has long struck me that the vast majority of pundits and commentators possess a shallow understanding of just how different other cultures are from their own personal experience of life in an American suburb. This misunderstanding predicates their failure, and indeed, the failure of American policy based on such wishful thinking.

To illustrate the point, I recommend a lengthy but deeply insightful piece in the current issue of The Atlantic entitled Point of No Return which explores how the supposedly "rogue" Pakistani nuclear scientist Khan was able to sell nuclear secrets to outlaw states like North Korea for his own personal gain.

I asked him how Khan could have gotten away with so much for so long. He said, "It is a cultural trait. The Western assumption that law should treat everyone the same way is no longer applicable in this country, in this culture. In Pakistan relationships exist only on an individual level, and as an individual I am entitled to forgive you or penalize you no matter what the law says. It is a feudal culture—or a degenerated feudal culture. That is why there is no law for the elites in Pakistan—why they do whatever they want to do. So your question of why nobody investigated A. Q. Khan? He must have had allies in high places who ignored his activities. You've given us the bomb. All power to you."
Next up: the incredibly swift rise of counterfeit drugs made in China, which are rapidly finding new markets in the U.S.: As Pfizer Battles Fakes in China, Nation's Police Are Uneasy Allies
Mr. Benner handed over a detailed report on the case and called a top Beijing cop whom he has worked with for years. Almost a year after Mr. Benner's initial approach, Chinese police conducted several major raids in August and September, arresting 12 people and seizing nearly half a million pills.

While police are sometimes helpful, Pfizer feels it is often bucking up against Beijing's "tacit acceptance of counterfeiting," says John Theriault, Pfizer's vice president of global corporate security.

Nowhere have counterfeiters grown more sophisticated than in China, where the manufacture of fake goods from computers to cars has taken off. Pirated copies of Western movies, such as "Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire" late last year, are available on the streets of Chinese cities just days after they're released in theaters. General Motors Corp. accused Chinese auto maker Chery Automobile Co., of using stolen design information to produce a car that is a virtual replica of GM's Spark minicar -- a claim the U.S. government publicly backs.
So the Chinese police jumped on the drug counterfeiting case post-haste and arrested a few people--a year later. Hmm. Do you reckon a few million possibly worthless or even dangerous pills got sold in that year? Let's be honest: if it takes a year to catch up with counterfeiters, just how effective can Beijing's anti-counterfeiting campaign be? Although the Chinese officials don't like hearing it, it is clearly a cultural issue: Chinese society routinely accepts counterfeiting as a "normal business."

So how are you going to make money in China when every one of your products is knocked off in days or weeks in quantities vast enough to cover the globe? Short answer: maybe you can't.

* * *

copyright © 2006 Charles Hugh Smith. All rights reserved in all media.

I would be honored if you linked this wEssay to your site, or printed a copy for your own use.


* * *
 
  weblog/wEssays     home