China's Challenges: U.S. Meltdown and Peak Oil (July 9, 2008) Knowledgeable reader Jason C. recently sent in a nuanced query about China which neatly summarizes the many conundrums facing both the Chinese and U.S. leaderships:
In her book China: Fragile Superpower: How China's Internal Politics Could Derail Its Peaceful Rise , Susan L. Shirk (former Deputy Secretary of State) talks about the large amount (hundreds of billions of dollars, and by now nearly a trillion) of US Government debt instruments owned by China which buoy our economy.Thank you, Jason, for an excellent and quite daunting set of questions. Let's begin with five short reports: first, a description of China: Fragile Superpower from amazon.com:
At a time when much writing about China frothily presumes the unstoppable rise of a global titan, it is refreshing that a respected academic and former government official (Shirk was the deputy assistant secretary of state for East Asia during the second Clinton administration) questions the notion that China is going to run the world. "China may be an emerging superpower," she writes, "but it is a fragile one."As for official China inflation: China's inflation rate dipped to a still high 7.7 percent in May, few saw reason to celebrate:
The rise in the consumer price index for May was lower than the 8.5 percent rise in April. Slower growth was widely anticipated thanks to state media reports suggesting the figure would be below 8 percent for the first time in four months.Next, we turn to China-based correspondent Mike D. for his response to my query about inflation in China as experienced by residents:
It was 7.7% annual in May. My wife feels that is 100% food and other supermarket necessaries since that is what she is most familiar with buying. Meat (pork and beef) are up 80-90% from last year. Cooking oil (Chinese go through it like water!) is up over 100%. Rice is higher in other parts of China, but the price seems to be controlled here at less than 20 cents a pound. As we live in the north, wheat is an important part of the diet and the price of flour is up about 50%. DVD's of recently released (like...today!) movies are still about 75 cents each for professional quality, so we must be thankful for small mercies!Thank you, Mike for a superb summary and incisive conclusion. Next, let's consider what Peak Oil is doing to the entire Asia-U.S. trade model (link courtesy of frequent contributor U. Doran): Oil price shock means China is at risk of blowing up (Telegraph.co.uk)
Asia's intra-trade model is a Ricardian network where goods are shipped in a criss-cross pattern to exploit comparative advantage. Profit margins are wafer-thin.Lastly, let's consider a two-part review of American decline: (links courtesy of correspondent Craig M.) America and China: The Eagle and the Dragon Part one: Freedom fighters (Telegraph.co.uk) America and China: The Eagle and the Dragon Part two: Requiem for a dream
But these developments have done little to alleviate the overwhelming impression of Detroit as a city of dereliction, poverty, crime and despair. The city's revival seemed to depend not on luring tourists for a day or two holed up in a casino, but persuading people it was a feasible place to live. As one downtown shopkeeper put it, 'the trouble is the infrastructure and services - garbage disposal, policing, upkeep - is so bad, that nobody in their right mind would want to live here. You call the cops and they probably won't even show up unless it's a murder. It's terrible.'To keep my response to Jason's questions shorter than booklength, here are what I consider the key points: 1. inflation is rising in China for two reasons: global demand for goods and the stupendous increase in money supply Jason described. Without going into detail, money is expanding in China the same way it expands elsewhere: via loans/new debt. Despite lingering bad debt (impaired loans) from the last downturn (2000-2002), the banks in China have created vast sums of new loans. In addition, the trade surplus with the U.S. brings in vast quantities of dollars, and "hot money" has flowed into China (legally and otherwise) to benefit from the appreciation of the RMB (yuan). As assets like stocks and real estate deflate/fall, then China faces the same problem the U.S. faces: bad debt, great mountains of it, which exceed the value of the assets purchased with debt (condos, municipal sports facilities, etc.) In other words, inflation isn't going away in China until global demand drops, and easy money/new loans dry up. In other words: recession. 2. Mike D. nailed it: China must manage the U.S. economy for its own benefit. The U.S. has no such challenge; it has benefitted enormously from trade with China in two ways: lower costs for manufactured goods and high corporate profits, which are 14% of U.S. GDP, an all-time high. The U.S. has little need (and virtually no leverage) to manage the Chinese economy; the cheap goods and the profits flow to the U.S. companies, and if the yuan gets too expensive, or oil keeps rising, then they move production elsewhere. Many observers claim China can "de-couple" from the U.S. and grow its economy by selling its stupendous manufacturing output to its domestic consumers. As I noted yesterday, this is based on flawed assumptions of the size of China's domestic economy: Those who believe China can "decouple" from the U.S. fail to weigh the reality that about 75% of the Chinese economy is export-based, in comparison to about 20% for exporting nations like the U.S. and Japan. Furthermore, China's GDP is grossly overstated by the usual purchasing power parity (PPP) methodology, as noted by Harold Brown of the Center for Strategic Studies in the March/April 2008 issue of Foreign Affairs:
Per capita GDP at PPP is a good measure of affluence, that is, the of the individual standard of living. Butt he appropriate measure of the potential influence of a national economy on the rest of the world is the national GDP at exchange rates.In other words, China is extraordinarily vulnerable to a reduction in exports. So how does China manage the U.S. economy? One, peg the yuan to the dollar (adjusted in careful, gradual increments), and Two, buy U.S. Treasuries to keep U.S. interest rates low to provide more fuel for U.S. consumers. Given all of the above, we have to ask: wouldn't it be economic suicide for China to dump its Treasuries, and thus political suicide for its leadership? The populace might well cheer the conquering of Taiwan for a week or two, and then as their livelihoods vanish, their euphoria and pride would soon turn to anger--an anger which would eventually turn toward the government which engineered their impoverishment. 3. Peak Oil is real, and it isn't going away. Yes, solar and other alternative energies may well replace much of the energy we currently obtain from oil, but that transition--taking solar and wind energy from less than 1% of global energy to 50% or more--will take a long time. In the meantime, global trade will become increasingly expensive and increasingly unprofitable. There is little China can do to bring oil down as supply falls (depletion) and demand rises (100 million scooters in India, etc.) I have written before that I expect one last "head-fake" of oil prices dropping as the global recession deepens, but falling supply will soon catch up with lower demand, and prices will leap beyond what most pundits think possible (try $1,000 a barrel). 4. Rising expectations are even more dangerous than inflation. I have long maintained that rising expectations are the key psychological driver behind widespread social turmoil. As Peak Oil guts the trade model China depends on for its wealth creation, and the purchasing power and wealth of its citizenry falls, China's leadership will face growing domestic unrest. Yes, it could distract the populace with a war for Taiwan; but as I said above, the financial cost to China would be essentially suicidal. (Note that Taiwanese investors own much of China's industrial base, and they may not consider the invasion just another ho-hum blip on the trading screen.) Then there's the possibility--never easy to parse ahead of time--that the invasion might escalate into a limited nuclear war. As covered here before, the more concentrated a nation's essential infrastructure is (think Three Gorges Dam), the greater the damage a few nukes can wreak. The U.S. has been engaged in a nearly permanant state of war for decades; would China's leaders really think the most warlike nation on the planet would turn away from conflict? Based on what evidence? I would summarize the dilemma China's leadership faces in this way: has the U.S. economy and the global trade/energy nexus slipped beyond its control? I would say yes. The U.S. is entering a long, deep and profound recession which will slash domestic consumption of Chinese-made goods. At the same time, the inexorable rise in oil prices has gutted the profitability of the Asian trade model for everything but high-value goods (solar panels, semiconductors, etc.) My premise about interest rates is based on these observable trends. As China's exports to the U.S. shrink, so too will its supply of surplus dollars, and thus its ability to keep buying hundreds of billions of additional U.S. Treasuries. With that key prop removed, then rates in the U.S. will have to rise, as the demand on the pool of available global cash made by staggering Federal deficits will exceed the supply of those willing to recklessly gamble on the dollar and the U.S. economy for a lousy 3.5% return for decades to come. Gold is another issue. Let's just say that gold tends to be horded and valued in times of insecurity and turmoil, and if you see insecurity ahead, then you will be unlikely to sell your gold to get renminbi or dollars or quatloos. Does China have enough gold and the political will to base its currency on gold? That's a speculation for another day. Here are several other China-related stories of note: China's Export Machine Threatened by Rising Costs Orders Drop, Shops Idle in Sweater City; Losing Wal-Mart inflation menace threatens asia decoupling Victim or Victor? China's Olympic Odyssey Resurgent nationalists are counting on a torrent of gold medals to erase centuries of humiliation. Will the Beijing Games complete a restoration of Chinese greatness or arrogance? The Cleveland of Asia: A Journey Through China’s Rust Belt
NOTE: contributions are acknowledged in the order received. Your name and email remain confidential and will not be given to any other individual, company or agency.
Thank you, Don E. ($13), for your continuing encouragement and contributions both financial
and intellectual to this site (You da Maine Man!)
I am greatly honored by your support and readership.
For more on this subject and a wide array of other topics, please visit my weblog. All content, HTML coding, format design, design elements and images copyright © 2008 Charles Hugh Smith, All rights reserved in all media, unless otherwise credited or noted. I would be honored if you linked this wEssay to your site, or printed a copy for your own use. |
consulting | blog fiction/novels articles my hidden history books/films what's for dinner | home email me | ||